Today's XKCD may as well have been written about Sorabji.com


sorabji.com: The Stalking Post: Today's XKCD may as well have been written about Sorabji.com
THIS IS A READ-ONLY ARCHIVE FROM THE SORABJI.COM MESSAGE BOARDS (1995-2016).

By semillama on Wednesday, December 18, 2013 - 10:14 am:


By heather on Wednesday, December 18, 2013 - 08:54 pm:

    Yes.


By ... on Wednesday, December 18, 2013 - 09:05 pm:

    this reminds me of something strange that happened
    some years ago, after Leslie Harpold died.

    i was looking at access_log files for a web site
    where the underground Scrabble site used to be.
    looking at that log file i noticed search engines
    were attempting to index one of those old scrabble
    URLs, which had not existed at that location for
    years.

    the scrabble URLs were woefully insecure by modern
    standards, but typical of mid-1990s web addresses
    which sometimes put passwords in the URL. for this
    reason i suggested using a throwaway password for
    Scrabble, since anyone walking past your computer
    could see it.

    the scrabble URLs looked something like this:

    /~sorabji//babel/boo/getpanel.pl?
    ID=abdvscah&PASSWORD=xiopxiop

    i was surprised to find that search engines were
    attempting to index the scrabble site, since there
    was no known public link to it. i searched Yahoo
    for "xiopxiop" (not the real password, i have no
    idea now what it was) and the only search result
    was a large text file sitting on one of Leslie's
    web sites. her sites remained online for a few
    years after she died.

    Leslie had noted her Scrabble URL (with the
    distinctive password) in this text file. this file
    was obviously not supposed to be on the public
    internet, but somehow it got indexed and made
    searchable by Yahoo and Google. the scrabble
    password was the least of the problems. the text
    file also had her checking account info and
    login/passwords for several web sites and
    services, ideas for domain names and web products,
    as well as pithy comments about other web sites
    and authors. it was like a diary, with random
    ideas and notes-to-self, which she seemed to have
    kept on her web site for convenience but which she
    most likely did not intend to make public.

    it took a little while to realize what i was
    looking at. it was eerie. i somewhat ruefully
    searched the document for my name, fearing she had
    nasty things to say about me, too, but i escaped
    that dagger.

    i don't remember how long i thought about it, but
    while trying to decide if i should contact someone
    from her family to take the page down the web site
    disappeared altogether.


By Antigone on Wednesday, December 18, 2013 - 10:40 pm:

    We are spirits
    In the material world


By Spider on Thursday, December 19, 2013 - 11:40 am:

    How did we find this place, anyway?

    I THINK I found it back when Yahoo would have indexes of "cool personal pages" or something like that, and I found the page of a girl named Evany Thomas (no relation; she is now a comedy writer, IIRC?). She had a link section on her site that included Mark's page, and she was really funny and interesting so I trusted her referral judgment.

    I remember when the boards were still in comments-tree format.


By droopy on Friday, December 20, 2013 - 03:02 am:

    i got here by way of agatha's old website. i think
    it was called "agatha frye's pies." there was a link
    to sorabji's forerunner "the place of general
    happiness." my handle here - droopy - was my online
    scrabble name.


By beta on Saturday, December 21, 2013 - 01:55 am:

    I'm reasonably certain I came from the mojave phone booth site, which was linked to me through a mailing list for the tv show "the adventures of pete and pete" which had an episode whose plot bore a passing resemblance to one blogger's story about the phone.

    I was on a lot of email lists in the 90's because that was the only way to obtain bootlegs- which were taped on dual cassette boomboxes and passed from member to member in the post. I got a lot of packages back then- from europe and australia especially, which was impressive, considering that the price for these bootlegs was never more than two blank tapes. One to fill with music and send back, one blank tape as compensation for the postage. It always felt so special to listen to the dim crackly recordings of live shows where my favorite bands were absolutely on fire; and I couldn't pass up the opportunity, so I was on mailing lists for every musician who was in any way special to me.

    Did I mention I was on a lot of lists? I was on a LOT of lists- soul coughing, guided by voices, pavement, tool, neutral milk hotel, etc etc. I was a subscriber to a list for Jeff Buckley when he disappeared into the mississippi river.

    There was a week before they found him where we all sat a vigil in front of our computers, hoping beyond hope that he had bumped his head and would be found wandering around memphis as an amnesiac, or that he had decided to disappear into the night and give up on fame.

    When they found his body, the grief ignited something in the lot of us- it felt like losing so much more than just a musical idol. So, many members started traveling around the country (and in a few instances around the globe) to meet one another and ostensibly hold memorial services.

    I traveled to new york for one of those services and met a girl there who worked in HR and hooked me up with a job that, once I had a few years under my belt, eventually allowed me to work in NYC.

    And I wanted to go to nyc because i had some kind of weird hero worship thing going on with MT in those days and saw his life as some sort of spiritual roadmap to my own (this is where I include a disclaimer about being a somewhat melodramatic college student). I'm sure I read every word of every story he ever published on the old site, and the new old site; and even though much of it was miserable and lonely it was the first time someone else's life really resonated with me. Cliched, but i really did feel less alone when I read the stories, or when bedcam would keep me company while I crammed a semester's worth of work into 48 hours. (Not to mention that the message boards were an incredible diversion when they were at their most active)

    As I got older, my dependence turned to concern- for several years i was truly fucking worried that mt would never manage to pull through.

    These days, I'm not so concerned- it seems like the old man has got his shit under control and that life is going pretty well- so i don't stop by as much as I did. It's probably been a few years since I properly read one of his stories, or mobile entries and I have no idea if he still does 'the big picture.' But then again, it seems less important to him too I'm no longer scouring his writings, pictures and receipts for some indication that he's on the verge of chasing a bottle of pills down with a bottle of wine.

    While I'm typing this all out, I feel like i should mention that I've told the saga of mt's bucket of change literally dozens of times. It's so satisfying to tell, and people fucking love to talk about how much they hate and/or save their change; so it's either a rebuke to demonstrate what they could do with their change if they just saved it, or vindication of there change-hoarding tendencies. I wonder if anyone has ever told MT the story of his own change bucket after I relayed it to them...


By Dr Pepper on Saturday, December 21, 2013 - 02:52 am:

    I don't know how I ended up on MT's site. because, I was concerning about payphone being dwindling at the turn of the century and thus enabled me to do the research on "Payphone Project". It is believed that there is only two payphones in my hometown. Last year, the public library voted to remove the payphone and I was deepened saddened by these assholes who voted to removed it.


By Antigone on Saturday, December 21, 2013 - 11:28 am:

    MT is a hero to all of us. Though the floaters in his eyes are
    the true hero. They keep him going and tell him shit.


By Spider on Monday, December 23, 2013 - 01:02 pm:

    Where are all the old writings?

    When I found sorabji.com, I was in college and didn't have a personal computer, so I had to read Mark's stories in the campus computer lab. They would make me laugh out loud, so I had to print them out and take them back to my dorm to read so I wouldn't disturb anyone.

    Now I can't find them on the main site.

    "An Open Letter to the Makers of Kool-Aid" and the story about Mark's friend from Oberlin (Peter?) were my favorites.


    He also wrote somewhere -- I think on WAYD -- about the personalities of all the musical scales. I'd like to find that again.


By ... on Monday, December 23, 2013 - 04:28 pm:


By Danielssss on Tuesday, December 24, 2013 - 02:51 am:

    Got here via a long train ride somewhere through
    the swamp between Texarkana Utah and that sassie
    mormon's undergarmets of god, then actually
    through the Un of Iowa wroters workshops and sarah
    there, a different sarah from our sarah here, and
    then through syrup.org and our sarah, somehow
    morphed over a few bales of cannabis lost in the
    Carribean sea floating by Heather and her Cuba,
    then here to MT's classical gas site.

    Must have been easier in the old days. Sarah made
    me do it. Then life as I knew unravelled in the
    sunset.


By Spider on Tuesday, December 24, 2013 - 10:37 am:

    YES

    Thank you for the links; I will have something to do at work today.

    Thanks also for the labor of digitizing the journal, The Etude, and allowing it to be accessed for free. What an amazing resource.

    A Bunch of Resolutions.

    1st. Resolved that, liking to see dignity well dressed, I shall take excellent care of my piano; shield it from sun and heat; use upon it a chamois, that it may not grow shabby, and a drop of alcohol, that its ivories may not grow yellow; never strike nor “bang” it; but always caress it and be to it the friend that it has been to me.

    2. Resolved that, as there are one hundred and sixty-eight hours in every week, I shall give at least one of these to reading musical literature.

    3d. Resolved, that I shall not say I hate anything that is music, but, if such should seem distasteful to me, to remain silent, out of respect to those who find something good in it.

    4th. Resolved, that I shall never refuse to play when asked to, nor appear to do so unwillingly, but always be glad to make music.


    The personalities of the scales. You called attributing states of mind to notes "poppycock," but they're there sometimes. Maybe not notes, but key signatures.


    Andrei Gavrilov playing Rachmaninoff's Elegie in E flat minor His performance is slaying me. Killing me dead on Christmas Eve.

    Typically you hear "elegy" and assume it will be quietly sad and wistful, but that piece is full of rage and agony. Feels like it could only have come from a Russian.


By platypus on Tuesday, December 24, 2013 - 09:27 pm:

    That XKCD is eerily accurate.

    Now I can't even remember how I found the boards, and this is
    going to bother me until I wake up in the middle of the night with
    an abrupt realisation. My first friends in the internet.


By la on Sunday, December 29, 2013 - 07:08 am:

    Spooky.

    I think it was a list of links on local
    alternative radio's website that got me here. Or
    maybe to the payphone project, but as a highschool
    girl I was a lot more interested in WAYD.

    Kinda funny... I was 17 or 18 when I first started
    posting, and now I'm a few weeks from 32. And
    I've never more than alluded to this place to
    anyone.

    There was also a link to a girl's diaryland page.
    It was password protected, but the password was
    included in the description, so I read about her
    exploits for two or three years.


By Danielssss on Tuesday, December 31, 2013 - 11:47 pm:

    either the neighbors have new cannons or it is
    thundersnowing here...happy new year you sorabjite
    people


By la on Wednesday, January 1, 2014 - 12:04 am:

    t-minus four hours to happy new year pst!


By Pepper on Wednesday, January 1, 2014 - 12:49 pm:

    The same to you too Danielsss! :-)


By la on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 02:18 am:

    we've got to keep it alive.

    finally have my new computer up and running....
    hooray for laptop and router talking to each other!

    i don't like checking sorabji on shared
    computers.... plus getting to the new messages page
    without a favorite is a pain. it's all fixed now.


By Ophelia on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 02:52 pm:

    Happy New Year to you all.

    I saw that xkcd too and immediately thought of sorabji.com.
    Consequently, this place had been rolling around in the back of my
    head, even though I'm pretty sure more than a few new year's eves
    have passed since I last stopped by. It just makes sense that you
    are already sitting here talking about the same comic. I guess that's
    just what this place is, because even though I've never been the
    most connected person on here, there were times in my life when
    this was where I felt most connected.

    I hope you all have been doing well. Best wishes for the new year.


By la on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 05:40 pm:

    Hi Ophelia!

    I get the least/most connected thing too. Sometimes
    I feel like I have a giant tattoo on my forehead
    "KILLS SUBJECTS".


By jaq on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 08:20 pm:

    happy 2014 to all!
    hope you are all well.
    jack is still fat and gay and won't admit it.
    be awesome, all.


By Pepper on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 10:14 pm:

    lol @ Mark, the third line was from V's line. So happy new year to you too........


By sarah on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 11:10 pm:

    nelly.


    and seriously, someone from these innards wrote that
    xkcd.



By sarah on Saturday, January 4, 2014 - 11:23 pm:

    i found sorabji via a personal journal website.
    (there was no such thing as a blog.) i don't
    remember which. back then all the links rotated
    to other personal journal websites, so who knows.
    back then the internet was such a tiny world.


    i traveled quickly from wayd to these boards. i
    used to read the stories, and look at the big
    pictures, but only occasionally.


    for more yeas than i can count i checked the
    boards at least once daily.


    it's definitely my hideaway.


    .
    ..
    ...
    ....
    .....
    ....
    ...
    ..
    .


By Ophelia on Wednesday, January 8, 2014 - 12:22 am:

    I first came here in 2001 while researching / procrastinating on a
    high school paper on Shakespearian tragic heroes. This thread
    htt
    p://sorabji.com/messages/649/4444.html
    showed up
    in some search. I was a little lost and had just read Hamlet. So I
    became Ophelia.

    It's funny, surprising, nostalgic, coming back here. I stayed up until
    the wee hours last night because I did a search and got caught up in
    re-reading the conversations my 18-20 year old self had within this
    community. I was trying to figure out the world, and who I was, by
    baring my inner anxieties along with my silliness to all of you who
    were older and wiser and more in the world. These pages were my
    connection to life outside of my high school existence and college
    campus, and played a significant part in my life.

    It seems like things have quieted down quite a bit. I wonder it it's
    just ebb and flow, or how much of it has to do with all of the other
    distractions of social media and virtual connectivity. Or whether we
    have found the communities we sought here to a greater degree in
    the people around us. Or maybe I've just caught a lull during the
    holiday season. I'm so glad to see that several of you still post
    here, though. Reading those old messages made me miss you.

    So maybe I'll come back and check in from time to time.


By Ophelia on Wednesday, January 8, 2014 - 12:35 am:

    Oh, and hi Pez! Had to scratch my head to figure out who you were.


By ... on Thursday, January 9, 2014 - 06:33 pm:

    i was talking to martin once about this web site.
    he was surprised when i made a distinction between
    these message boards and what i called "the
    sorabji part of sorabji.com," meaning the big
    pictures and ramblings and other stuff. he seemed
    to think they were all in the same realm but i do
    not. this part of the site has a life of its own,
    which is something like what i had in mind
    when i set it up.
    this place (these message
    boards) has always been important to me. it's
    where i came after my father's suicide, it's the
    first thing i restored after the server blowout of
    a few years ago, and it's the first thing i plan
    around when moving this web site to another server
    or hosting company.
    i don't think this place would
    ever go away as long as i'm around. someone has
    suggested i donate some or all of sorabji.com to
    archive.org. meh, idunno.
    like others, i do not mention this place to anyone
    any more, though i guess i talked about it more in
    earlier years.
    posting here feels like i'm cheating on something
    (but what?) and i only do it when no one else is
    around.
    needless to say, the www's landscape for this sort
    of thing has changed, but i'm happy that this
    place survives in its original form... unless by
    "original" you remember the bulleted-list format
    that used to be at
    http://bbs.sorabji.com/tpogh/clink/bbs/ .
    That old format used to be archived at the wayback
    machine but it's gone now. Maybe it's on a tape
    drive somewhere in my storage room...


By Jaq on Thursday, January 9, 2014 - 10:28 pm:

    i have always thought the bbs boards were separate from the other stuff. but i didn't have any idea what you thought. i do remember the bullet-list format but i never posted then. glad you're still around. think of you every time i see the review avenue wall and a number of other spots locally.


By platypus on Thursday, January 9, 2014 - 11:33 pm:

    Sorabji.com is always in my heart. I think of the gang often.


By Antigone on Thursday, January 9, 2014 - 11:39 pm:

    I make occasional backups with wget. It's been a couple of years
    since the last one, though.


By Ophelia on Friday, January 10, 2014 - 12:14 am:

    Thanks, Mark, for keeping it going.


By on Friday, January 10, 2014 - 11:04 am:

    Way to go Mark, Rock on!!!!


By la on Saturday, January 11, 2014 - 01:02 am:

    And yes. Mark is awesome.

    I've had a number of name changes over the
    years...
    when I came back after a break I started posting
    as
    la and was mistaken for another.... cyst, if I
    remember correctly.

    Oh Hamlet.

    Which reminds me..... has anyone read MacBeth?


By Ophelia on Saturday, January 11, 2014 - 07:10 pm:


By Danielssss on Sunday, January 12, 2014 - 12:04 am:

    Wee sleekit cowring tim'rous beastie it is indeed.
    Alas, poor mark, no one (may have) knew (known)
    him well, at
    least his legend lived on in through and within
    the intoxicated
    piano scales and lithuanian inspired accordian
    stories of these boards, Anti's marraiges and
    patrick's babies, all of our divorces and the
    pexmobile bicycle races,
    sprinkled with irish faerie doctor dust (think
    river drum) and west coast fuck you you
    ass isms,(think Oakland and sweet heather)
    surrounded in scanned receipts and big pictures of
    city cemateries, mausoleums of such souls as may
    inhabit here, wrinkled pocket fuzz at droopy's
    favorite liquor dispensary,
    and meaningful payphone numbers at the base of the
    eiffiel tower (cuff the french)...Hi
    Ophelia...this sagacious
    rag and bone shop of the heart (bly, look it up)
    continues to prove my disconnection to the
    universe
    at large. Before marriage, we had loved each other
    in the starlight. (maupassant)


By Danielssss on Sunday, January 12, 2014 - 12:15 am:

    reference to Maupassant's text: first two
    paragraphs explain it all: "She loved him because
    it is natural for young ladies to love young men
    who say tender words to them."

    <a
    href="http:
    //books.google.com/books?

    id=6NhDAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA204&ots=WyNuFwkuLs&dq=maupas
    sant%20forbidden%20fruit&pg=PA204&ci=223%2C565%2C6
    06%2C655&source=bookclip"><img
    src="http:/
    /books.google.com/books?

    id=6NhDAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA204&img=1&zoom=3&hl=en&sig=AC
    fU3U0PQ7xytaQ4UK242H5wQ68Cxp3abw&ci=223%2C565%2C60
    6%2C655&edge=0"/></a>


By The Watcher on Sunday, January 12, 2014 - 05:08 am:

    Ah. Memories. I can to this wondrous land via the Payphone Project.

    Back those many years ago my wife and I were getting some strange phone calls and I wanted away to find the payphone he was using.

    So many woes have come and gone since then. That was before my wife's MS. Back before my depression hit me hard.

    One again I too thank Mark for keeping it going.


By la on Sunday, January 12, 2014 - 09:17 pm:

    I do genealogy projects from time to time. It's
    mildly interesting and I like knowing a little bit
    about my family. My mom grew up in a household
    that didn't talk about where they came from and
    half my dad's family came from Norway 100 years
    ago, but before that, nothing.

    So one time I started following a thread and it
    went back and back and the names started looking
    more and more important. And old.

    I stopped a couple generations after Maldred
    MacCrinian back in the 11th century. Maldred was
    the younger (half) brother of Duncan I of
    Scotland, the king assassinated by MacBeth in his
    lust for power. It was in the early days of
    kingships being hereditary in Scotland; MacBeth
    was their cousin. Maldred and Crinian had no
    claims to the throne (it was Duncan's mother who
    was a princess) and so they threw themselves into
    battle, avenging Duncan and supporting his sons.

    It's interesting to have some ties to a story, but
    if you can find records that go back that far
    someone thought it was important to record them.


By Ophelia on Sunday, January 12, 2014 - 09:24 pm:

    Maldred MacCrinian. Fantastic!

    So were they the ones that came up with the idea of
    carrying trees and branches to hide behind when they
    attacked the castle?


By La on Monday, January 13, 2014 - 01:45 am:

    i have no clue


By Danielssss on Monday, January 13, 2014 - 06:35 pm:

    geneological research done in my family takes us
    back to 850 at Caernavon Castle in Scotland. My
    aunt says the german side came directly from
    germany in 1700-1800's; the irish side says we
    black irish (a derogatory term) came from olive
    skinned portugese sailors intermarrying with fair
    irish lassies after 1500. the swedish side of the
    family, says whatever, and drinks wine, thinking
    that before the coal mines in pennsylvania, they
    must have come from sweden.

    I still am disconnected from the universe.


By Spider on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 10:35 am:


By Pepper on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 11:03 am:

    Thank you for the information, Spider. I find this interesting.


By Danielssss on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 12:06 pm:

    I am still disconnected from the universe.
    "Debunked" seems a strong and misleading term; on
    the contrary your citation provides credence to the
    use of the term over centuries and in differing
    contexts. Nonetheless, I am still disconnected from
    the universe, en masse and in particular. I am
    still your friend too.


By droopy on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 12:43 pm:

    i found that interesting, too. i'd never heard the
    term "black irish" used, but my grandmother told
    us that my father - who has dark hair and blue
    eyes - had the true "hibernian" coloring.
    suggesting that they came from the iberian
    peninsula. my grandfather was a member of the
    ancient order of hibernians.

    i looked it up just now, and found that the two
    words - hibernia and iberia - are actually
    unrelated and any similarity coincidental.

    not that my father would care. my family is either
    embarrassed or ashamed of his family history, and
    refuses to talk about it.


By Danielssss on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 02:41 pm:

    I aM GLAD THAT Droopy and i are Swedish. Here's to
    you buddy.


By Spider on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 02:48 pm:

    That link explained why the theory that the Black Irish are descended from Portuguese or Spanish people is unlikely to be true.

    Unless you're talking about Eamon de Valera, in which case it is true.

    And we'd better still be friends, mister!


    Family legend is that the house in which my grandfather was raised, on King St. in Lower Manhattan, had at one time belonged to Aaron Burr. I don't think there's any illustrious person in my direct family line, though.


By Antigone on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 03:59 pm:

    I'm half Swedish. My mom's side of the family came over in the
    early 20th century, mostly from the Umeå area.


By droopy on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 05:13 pm:

    i'm full celt: irishwelshscot. i like dan'lsss's
    idea; i think i'm going to be swedish this month.
    except for the weekend after next, when i will be
    manouche. i don't know yet what i will be for
    february.

    are we still friends, spider? of course!


By Pepper on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 08:18 pm:

    Wow, My mom's family is a Irish, as for my dad's family is a German-Russian. It is not easy being Irish/ German-Russian, cause, sometimes my life is upside down....


By Ophelia on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 09:47 pm:

    I've got English, Irish, French, and some kind of Scandinavian, but
    no one's really sure about that part.

    White, like most of you, as far as I can assume from your European
    heritage.

    I just (about an hour ago) had a really intense conversation about
    race with an old friend of mine. She uses her facebook page to post
    a lot of thought provoking and sometimes challenging articles that I
    read and learn from, with a general unifying theme of how white
    feminism is fucked up and how white people are either blatantly
    ignorant about race and white privilege or how their (our) attempts
    at being allies are misguided. I really appreciate all that she has to
    say, and how it challenges me. I also had recently been feeling
    frustrated that I felt like in everything she posted there were no
    examples of a white person making a statement or an action as an
    ally that was actually a positive contribution, and I brought this up
    in conversation. She responded, and I really respect her response,
    that it's not her job to find these stories or congratulate white
    people for doing the right thing (and that furthermore there may
    not be that many instances or examples out there). Which I get. As
    a result we had an intense and challenging conversation. Part of the
    upshot was that if white people want to have a dialogue about race,
    we can't expect black people to be our guides, we have to take it on
    and navigate it ourselves.

    This makes sense to me and I've been chewing this over. Curious
    what you all think. Why are white people so unlikely to bring up
    race except when in a room with someone of color? And what can
    white people accomplish through dialogue about race?


By Antigone on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 - 10:41 pm:

    I just treat people like people. If they want to be neurotic about
    race that's their problem.


By Spider on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 09:40 am:

    White people are used to being the center of the discussion -- like 98% of media is targeted to a white audience, the white experience is the "default" -- and it tends to make us uncomfortable when the discussion strays from us to another group. It can be hard for people to refrain from dragging the conversation back around to our experiences instead of just being quiet and listening to what members of the other group have to say.

    Also, people have a blindspot, where if they don't see something happening, and you say it happened, they won't believe you.

    I see a correlation with gender here.

    Just as an example, how many goddamned discussions have I had with men who don't believe women are catcalled as much as they are, because they don't see it? And then they feel compelled to chime in with their own stories of some time a homeless guy yelled at them or something, as if that's at all analogous to the consistent and pervasive street harassment that women deal with? And then in most cases in my experience, they flip the fuck out when we point out that they don't know what they're talking about, they don't know what we have experienced, they're telling us we're exaggerating or lying about our own experiences, and they should just be quiet for once and listen to what we're saying and understand that this happens more than they're aware of.

    So I see a direct analogy here with white people getting into conversations with black people about race. In my daily life, I hardly ever encounter anyone openly being racist or discriminatory toward black people, but I would be a giant idiot if I thought that because I don't see it, it must not happen. If I'm in a group with black people talking about their experiences with bigotry, I'm not going to say, "I know what you're talking about...some guy called me a cracker the other day, can you believe it?" as if that's on par with systemic discrimination. I'm not going to listen to black women talking about their struggles with their hair and chime in with, "I know what you mean, my hair gets so frizzy when it rains!" because I'm aware of the cultural issues involving black women's hair and my experience with my own hair is not the same.

    Even when I was a racial minority (when I lived on a reservation), the power balance was still tipped in my favor. One of the men I worked with told me not to walk in town after dark, but then added, "but everyone knows that if an Indian rapes a white girl, he's going down, so you'd probably be the safe." This alone tells me I don't know what it's like to a minority in a majority-white world.




By Spider on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 10:08 am:

    Gah, sorry, I don't mean to say that I have all the answers or anything....just that this is what I have learned so far.


By ... on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 11:19 am:

    Well apparently that La and Danielssss bought it up.


By Karla on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 04:48 pm:

    I found these boards from the NYT article on MT's pay phone project. I saw xkcd and thought the same thing as Semillama. It's been fascinating to follow the folks on here and watch everyone's lives evolve. I wonder if we'll ever meet one day, or if that would just be awkward and weird.


By Ophelia on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 06:08 pm:

    So true, Spider, that we can't know what it is to
    walk in someone else's shoes.

    Like you, I reach for analogies within my
    experience to try and gain some perspective of
    what it is navigate the world from within in a
    disenfranchised group. At the same time, I
    recognize that white privilege is not the same as
    male privilege, is not the same as straight or
    cisgender privilege, is not the same as
    socioeconomic or linguistic or able-bodied
    privilege, and the list goes on. So there are real
    limits to how much we can "get it" by analogy.

    But to your point about wanting to turn the
    conversation to ourselves, I think that in some
    ways we need to turn the conversation to
    ourselves, to figure out the ways that we
    subconsciously play out the role of privilege, and
    to catch ourselves and each other when that
    happens, and I think my friend's point was that
    that part is our job. It doesn't have to mean
    interrupting someone else's dialogue, and it
    certainly can't take the place of listening to
    someone who is in a disenfranchised group speak to
    their perspective. Being quiet and listening
    definitely is a part of what we need to do too.
    But at some point the learning and reflection
    needs to show up in action or conversation, right?
    I don't necessarily mean a deliberate action or
    conversation, but a shift in the actions and
    conversations of daily life. Or something like
    that. That's the part I'm trying to figure out.


    All that any of us has to go on is what we have
    learned so far. And I get stumped with this a
    lot, so I figure I have a lot of learning to do.


By Antigone on Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 07:44 pm:

    Karla, what's wrong with awkward and weird? I've come to
    enjoy awkward and weird.

    If I ever make lots of money you're all invited on an all expense
    paid trip somewhere.


By heather on Thursday, January 16, 2014 - 05:49 pm:

    Many of us have met.

    Some of us are awkward and weird.

    At this point I guess it is possible I have met the most,
    unless y'all do it in secret.


By la on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 02:05 am:

    Hrm... I've met you, TBone, Phant6m, Hal, Agatha
    (long long ago) and Tom showed up at my work once
    (and then failed to meet me in downtown Portland
    another time) way way waaaaay back.

    Inside we're all awkward and weird and full of blood
    and guts.


By The Watcher on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 04:35 am:

    My father once told me that we were mutts. Having spent several months now on ancestry.com I can clearly state he was correct.

    I am Irish, Scottish, English, French, German, Swiss. And, I'm still looking.

    I also know I am very distantly related to Robert Duvall.


By The Watcher on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 05:01 am:

    As far as racial privilege goes. The only people concerned with racial privilege are rich white liberals, rich black "leaders", and the poor blacks that have bought into this. It takes hard work and determination to earn your place in society. Unless your are born rich.

    I have no respect for those that say I owe them simply because some of my ancestors owned a slave or two before 1850. I worked my butt off for what little I have. And, the only privilege I ever saw was when I got my first job emptying trash cans at a local department store because my father had a part time sales job there and it was a "family" type of business. Almost everyone there had a relative that worked for the store.

    I have known a lot of Black people personally in my life. The ones who have my respect worked for everything they had. And, none of them complained about being oppressed.


By heather on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 03:56 pm:


By Ophelia on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 03:58 pm:

    You are right that not everyone talks about privilege. I didn't
    seriously consider privilege for years, but my eyes have opened
    little by little. That doesn't mean it doesn't impact all of our lives.

    I don't think it's about what you owe someone exactly. It's about
    working to create a level playing field, not because there has been a
    (much more dramatically) uneven field historically, but because
    there is still an uneven field today.

    The thing about privilege is that we don't always see it. If you
    haven't seen Peggy McIntosh's article comparing privilege to an
    invisible backpack, I think it does a good job explaining. You can
    find the whole thing but here's an excerpt:

    http://www.deanza.edu/faculty/lewisjulie/White%20Priviled
    ge%20U

    npacking%20the%20Invisible%20Knapsack.pdf


By Ophelia on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 04:01 pm:

    :-) Heather I immediately thought of those same two articles.


By blindswine on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 06:05 pm:


By Danielssss on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 06:46 pm:

    I've been mistaken for being red skinned native
    american indian, and treated differently until I
    corrected the error in assumption on the
    observer's part, and then I was treated ... how?
    like? WTF being of irish or German or swedish or
    lithuanian descent has nothing to do with race nor
    ethnicity, technically speaking. My good friend
    and colleague speaks worldwide about cultural
    sensitivity, primarily from her perspective of a
    multi- PhD'd tall athletic vegan religion
    (christian) feminist professor at a prestigious
    ivy league school, and she misses the mark
    repeatedly: culture by definition is about the
    culture (think petri dish) in which the child
    grows into an adult, i.e., family values
    regardless of color race ethnicity or descent.
    These are all variables, and not interchangeable.

    Hey mark every time I backspace or hit return with
    my cursor, I get pixelads opening in new windows.
    Just saying.

    Love you Heather and Spider, Anti and Droop, Semi
    and Agatha, and SarAH and la, blindswine, Tbone
    and Czarina (if you're lurking), those from down
    under and across the pond, and ... everyone (well
    most). I've met only two of you in the flesh, but
    I think I know so many without that meeting. And
    I value this place like a secret garden on a
    desert island in a universe far far away.

    Any body roasting green coffee beans? I did some
    today slow and low and the house smells so fine.


By la on Friday, January 17, 2014 - 10:20 pm:

    I haven't roasted any for months, but I have a bag
    on the top shelf, waiting for me to fill the house
    with smoke.

    A friend taught me to roast coffee. We both had
    breakups at the same time so for a while we'd get
    together every few weeks to drink beer and make
    pad thai. Our hugs are always awkward, because
    every time I remember how much he loves wool.

    Maybe I'll roast some tomorrow or Monday, and
    winnow the chaff in the sun.


By JusMiceElf on Saturday, January 18, 2014 - 12:16 pm:

    I think I found the Payphone Project first, then stayed for the
    boards. I've been here off and on since the mid 90s. Moved,
    married, had kids, and divorced in that time. I don't always say
    much, but I keep coming back to check in on y'all. Never met
    anyone in person, played a few games of scrabble, or maybe
    backgammon along the way.


By Danielssss on Sunday, January 19, 2014 - 04:01 pm:

    @la, i almost bought a roaster with a catalytic
    converter, but the reviews pointed me toward a
    smaller, less expensive more efficient SR500 made
    in the US, and I like it. Used without the
    Kitchen hood running,(I have a big semi commercial
    job and use the roaster close to it usually) it
    still produces very little smoke even at a nine
    minute, two crack roast...

    It's the breasts against soft merino or alpaca
    wool that is meaningful.


By The Watcher on Monday, January 20, 2014 - 02:17 am:

    heather,

    Our opinions may be disgusting to each other. But, that does not mean that I don't love you.

    Bleeding liberal that you are.


bbs.sorabji.com
 

The Stalking Post: General goddam chit-chat Every 3 seconds: Sex . Can men and women just be friends? . Dreamland . Insomnia . Are you stoned? . What are you eating? I need advice: Can you help? . Reasons to be cheerful . Days and nights . Words . Are there any news? Wishful thinking: Have you ever... . I wish you were... . Why I oughta... Is it art?: This question seems to come up quite often around here. Weeds: Things that, if erased from our cultural memory forever, would be no great loss Surfwatch: Where did you go on the 'net today? What are you listening to?: Worst music you've ever heard . What song or tune is going through your head right now? . Obscure composers . Obscure Jazz, 1890-1950 . Whatever, whenever General Questions: Do you have any regrets? . Who are you? . Where are you? . What are you doing here? . What have you done? . Why did you do it? . What have you failed to do? . What are you wearing? . What do you want? . How do you do? . What do you want to do today? . Are you stupid? Specific Questions: What is the cruelest thing you ever did? . Have you ever been lonely? . Have you ever gone hungry? . Are you pissed off? . When is the last time you had sex? . What does it look like where you are? . What are you afraid of? . Do you love me? . What is your definition of Heaven? . What is your definition of Hell? Movies: Last movie you saw . Worst movie you ever saw . Best movie you ever saw Reading: Best book you've ever read . Worst book you've ever read . Last book you read Drunken ramblings: uiphgy8 hxbjf.bklf ghw789- bncgjkvhnqwb=8[ . Payphones: Payphone Project BBS
 

sorabji.com . torturechamber . px.sorabji.com . receipts . contact