THIS IS A READ-ONLY ARCHIVE FROM THE SORABJI.COM MESSAGE BOARDS (1995-2016). |
---|
|
Hold me. |
|
|
|
When you know someone well though, you get to guess their moods or what they are thinking. It's nice sometimes to be that close to someone. |
|
You lost me after Human Rade? Love,RB |
Love, SW |
"It is true that not an idea in any sermon but had been presented through an unbroken continuity of nearly a hundred years, but rarely with such zeal and fire." |
it is archaic and difficult to understand. it does not feel grammatically correct, but i'm not actually sure. it is a shitty sentence by modern measure, grammatical or not. |
It's from "The New England Clergy and the American Revolution", by Alice Baldwin, c1928. I didn't read on to see if she was always this awkward. |
it also looks like she uses "but" in an old-timey way i still hear occasionally: like, "i knew a boy lived around here but was a fine fella." |
it seems to be missing its subject. |
the second 'but' could be right: 'the idea had been presented before through the past hundred years, but rarely with such zeal and fire.' just from that sentence (the one spider quotes) it's hard to tell if the woman means ideas in general or one idea in particular not being presented so strongly. but now that i see it's about the new england clergy and the american revolution, its probably one in particular. maybe its something like the moral stance for or against england - you know, the revolution was being fomented in the church. at least it clears up the clumsy "unbroken continuity of nearly a hundred years" part for me. but spider will have to tell me if i'm even close on the other stuff. this is a fun game. |
I failed to record the other sentences around this one, but I seem to recall this being the start of a paragraph. I had to catalog this book at work, and as I was flipping through, I saw that this sentence had been underlined and highlighted with stars in the margin. Maybe the stars were the polite way of indicating "WTF?!?!" |
this morning, as i lay in bed at 5am being molested by a cat, i noticed the similarity between "not an idea in any sermon" and "not a day goes by." the sentence haunts me. |